10 Best Baby Crib Mattresses 2025 in the United States

The Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed stands out in the baby mattress category thanks to its unique features aimed at enhancing safety and comfort. Its patented Wovenaire breathe-thru core is a highlight, ensuring excellent breathability that helps reduce the risk of suffocation and overheating, which is a key concern for parents. This innovative design allows you to rest easy knowing your baby is safe while sleeping.

One of the standout strengths is its complete washability. The mattress isn’t just about comfort; it prioritizes hygiene too. Both the cover and the core can be easily washed, making it a practical choice for new parents dealing with inevitable nighttime accidents or allergens. This ease of cleaning contributes to a healthier sleep environment, which is crucial for babies.

The firm support offered by this mattress is ideal for infants and toddlers, providing a 2-stage design that meets the needs of growing children. The absence of harmful materials like foam, glue, and latex adds to its appeal, with certifications like GREENGUARD GOLD assuring parents of its low chemical emissions.

The Graco Premium Crib & Toddler Mattress is designed with safety and comfort in mind, making it a solid choice for parents looking for a reliable sleeping surface for their little ones. One of its standout features is the GREENGUARD Gold and CertiPUR-US certifications, which ensure that the mattress meets strict safety standards and promotes healthier indoor air quality. This is particularly beneficial for parents who are cautious about potential chemical exposure in baby products.

In terms of firmness, this mattress provides a supportive feel that is generally recommended for infants, helping to reduce the risk of suffocation. Additionally, its waterproof outer cover is a big plus, as it protects against spills and makes cleaning a breeze, thanks to its machine-washable feature. The ultra-soft cover is also designed to minimize noise during movement, promoting a more peaceful sleep environment.

While the mattress is designed to fit standard crib sizes, its thickness of 4.5 inches may not be as robust as some parents prefer for extended use into toddler years. Some users may also find that it requires a short break-in period to achieve optimal firmness after unpacking. Moreover, despite its positive safety ratings, it’s essential for parents to ensure the mattress fits snugly in their crib to prevent any gaps. With a 10-year limited warranty, it offers assurance of durability. However, it's worth noting that the mattress is made from foam, which can sometimes retain heat. Parents looking for a highly breathable option may want to consider that aspect. The Graco Premium Crib & Toddler Mattress is a strong candidate for parents focused on safety and ease of maintenance, but some may want to weigh the factors of thickness and heat retention in their decision-making.

The Naturepedic Organic Crib Mattress is designed with baby safety and comfort in mind, offering a firm, supportive surface that meets pediatric recommendations for infants and toddlers. Its 2-stage design means it starts off firmer for newborns and becomes a bit softer as your child grows, making it a practical choice to use for several years. Made with 100% organic cotton and certified to be non-toxic, this mattress helps reduce exposure to harmful chemicals, which is great for health-conscious parents. The mattress also features a patented sugarcane-based waterproof coating that keeps it easy to clean with just soap and water, without sacrificing breathability.

This breathable design promotes airflow, helping your baby sleep more comfortably and reducing the risk of overheating. In terms of size, it fits standard cribs and toddler beds, so it can grow with your child. One of its standout features is how lightweight it is—only about 11 to 14 pounds—making sheet changes and moving the mattress easier than many traditional coil mattresses. However, while the mattress is praised for its organic materials and safety, some users might find the price is higher compared to non-organic options.

Although the mattress is designed to be breathable, very hot climates may still require additional measures to keep your baby cool. If you prioritize organic materials, safety certifications, and a mattress that adapts as your child grows, this would be a strong choice. If budget is a major concern or you need a mattress with extra cooling features, you might want to explore other options.