10 Best Electric Fireplace Insert For Existing Fireplace 2025 in the United States

The PuraFlame Western 33" Electric Fireplace Insert is designed to fit an existing fireplace space with overall dimensions of 44.1" wide, 31.5" high, and 8.8" deep. It offers a realistic flame effect with three settings for intensity and brightness, and its resin log and ember bed mimic the look of a wood-burning fireplace. The insert also includes a remote control for convenience and an adjustable thermostat, allowing it to provide supplemental heat for rooms up to 400 sq. ft. However, it is not intended as a primary heat source.

Installation is straightforward as the unit can be placed directly on the floor and plugged into a standard 120V outlet, but it cannot be hard-wired, which might limit placement options for some users. The unit is energy-efficient, utilizing LED technology for flame effects, and comes with safety features like a cool-touch surface and overheat protection.

Some potential downsides include its inability to serve as a main heat source and the fact that it comes in two packages, which may arrive on different days. Additionally, while customer service is noted as responsive, the one-year warranty might seem limited compared to other products in the market.

The PuraFlame Klaus 33” Electric Fireplace Insert is designed to fit into existing fireplaces, offering a realistic fire experience with minimal maintenance. It measures 44.1 inches wide, 31.5 inches high, and 10 inches deep. This fireplace insert stands out with its realistic flame effect and resin logs, creating a cozy atmosphere with three flame settings that can be adjusted for intensity and brightness.

Users can enjoy the ambiance of a fire all year round thanks to the energy-saving LED technology that works with or without the heat function. The heating capacity is suitable for rooms up to 400 sq. ft., making it a good supplemental heat source but not sufficient as the main heating system for larger areas. Installation is straightforward as it can simply sit on the floor and plug into a standard 120V outlet, though it cannot be hardwired.

Safety features include a glass door and mesh screen, along with an adjustable thermostat for user convenience. It also comes with a remote control, adding to its ease of use. However, the fireplace insert arrives in two packages, which might be delivered on separate days. This product combines traditional style with modern convenience, offering a hassle-free and visually appealing option for enhancing any living room.

The LegendFlame Carl 39" W Electric Fireplace Insert (EF265) is designed to fit into an existing fireplace, making it a practical choice for those looking to modernize their living space without the hassle of traditional wood or gas fireplaces. The insert measures 10.39"D x 38.66"W x 26.11"H and includes a life-like resin log, enhancing the visual appeal with its realistic flame effect and multiple brightness settings. The nine different mood light settings provide versatility, making it suitable for various occasions and moods.

The sleek design, featuring a three-sided interior brick wall and clean glass front trim, adds a contemporary touch to any room. The unit is designed for free-standing installation and plugs into a standard 120v 15amp outlet, but it does not support hard-wired installation. A key feature is the adjustable thermostat, which allows you to set the desired temperature, and the remote control facilitates easy operation. The fireplace has a heating capacity suitable for spaces up to 400 sq. ft., making it a great supplemental heat source but not adequate as the main heat source for larger areas.

Safety features include a vent-free design and a powder-coated finish for durability. While the product offers good energy efficiency with a maximum power consumption of 1500 watts, it may not be the best option for those seeking a primary heating solution. The unit weighs 66 pounds and comes with a one-year limited warranty, with customer service readily available for assistance. The LegendFlame Carl 39" W Electric Fireplace Insert (EF265) is a solid choice for those looking to add ambiance and supplemental warmth to their living room with ease and style.