10 Best Fish Smoker 2025 in the United States

The Weber Searwood XL 600 Pellet Smoker Grill is a large, versatile smoker that can be a great choice for anyone serious about smoking fish or other foods outdoors. Its pellet fuel system offers precise temperature control ranging from 180°F to 600°F, which means it can handle gentle smoking at low heat as well as high-temperature searing. This flexibility is ideal for fish smoking, where maintaining a steady low temperature is important for good flavor and texture. The smoker heats up quickly and recovers temperature fast if you open the lid, helping to keep cooking consistent even in cooler weather. The direct flame cooking feature and full grate sear zone give you more options for crisping and browning, which adds nice flavor layers beyond just smoking.

With a cooking area of 36 inches and two-level racks, the grill offers ample space for larger batches, making it suitable for gatherings or frequent cooking. The stainless steel and alloy steel build, combined with a painted finish, suggest solid durability and good heat retention, but the smoker's weight of about 190 pounds means it’s not very portable—best suited for a fixed outdoor spot. The inclusion of Wi-Fi and Bluetooth connectivity along with a food probe allows convenient temperature monitoring through an app, which is helpful if you want to keep track without constantly checking the grill.

Cleaning is somewhat easier thanks to the design, but pellet smokers generally require more maintenance than simpler charcoal or gas smokers due to the pellet system. The smoker also supports additional accessories like a griddle insert and rotisserie, expanding its versatility but adding to the cost if you want those features. This Weber smoker provides excellent temperature control, build quality, and cooking capacity for fish smoking and more. Its large size and weight reduce portability, and it may need regular cleaning to keep the pellet system running smoothly. It represents a solid choice if you want a high-performance smoker with smart features and are okay with a heavier, less portable unit.

The Traeger Grills TFB97JLH Woodridge Pro is a versatile wood pellet grill and smoker, perfect for those who value authentic wood-fired flavor without the hassle of gas or charcoal. Its 6-in-1 functionality allows you to grill, smoke, bake, roast, braise, and BBQ, making it highly versatile for various cooking needs. With a large 970 sq. in. cooking space, this smoker is ideal for cooking for large groups or family gatherings.

The precision temperature control ranges from 180-500°F, ensuring you can manage the heat for different types of cooking, from low-and-slow smoking to searing steaks. The digital controller with Keep Warm and Super Smoke modes is a noteworthy feature for achieving optimal flavor and cooking results. Build quality is robust, with a metal frame and stainless steel handle, ensuring durability. However, at 174 pounds, it’s quite heavy and less portable.

Cleaning is simplified with the EZ-Clean Grease & Ash Keg, but assembly is required, which could be a downside for some users. The WiFi and app connectivity add a modern touch, allowing you to control and monitor the grill remotely. Despite its higher price range, the combination of features and build quality makes it a strong contender for outdoor cooking enthusiasts looking for a reliable, high-capacity smoker.

The Traeger Grills Pro 22 Electric Wood Pellet Grill and Smoker is ideal for those who love the rich flavor of wood-fired cooking without the hassle of gas or charcoal. It offers versatility with its 6-in-1 capabilities to not only grill and smoke but also bake, roast, braise, and BBQ, making it a comprehensive solution for various cooking methods.

This smoker has a generous cooking area of 572 square inches, which is sufficient to cook for a moderate-sized gathering, accommodating up to 4 chickens, 5 racks of ribs, or 24 burgers at once. The precision temperature control feature is a significant advantage, maintaining temperatures within +/- 15 degrees F, ensuring consistent cooking results up to 450°F. Built with sturdy steel and a durable powder coat finish, it's designed to last and withstand the elements.

The porcelain grill grates are straightforward to clean, adding to its user-friendly design. However, at 125.4 pounds, it is quite heavy, which might affect portability despite its all-terrain wheels. Also, since it is corded electric, you’ll need access to a power outlet, which might limit where you can use it. This smoker is best suited for someone who prioritizes flavor and versatility in their outdoor cooking, but it might be cumbersome if frequent moving is required.