We Use CookiesWe use cookies to enhance the security, performance, functionality and for analytical and promotional activities. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our privacy policy

10 Best Mtg Commander Decks 2025 in the United States

How do we rank products for you?

Our technology thoroughly searches through the online shopping world, reviewing hundreds of sites. We then process and analyze this information, updating in real-time to bring you the latest top-rated products. This way, you always get the best and most current options available.

headphones-stars

Our Top Picks

#1

Winner

Magic: The Gathering Fallout Commander Deck Bundle – Includes All 4 Decks (1 Hail Caesar, 1 Scrappy Survivors, 1 Science!, and 1 Mutant Menace)

Rating
9.8
Chosen by1,335
Commander (General)
Card Synergy

Most important from
2398 reviews

Commander (General)
The Mutant Menace deck introduces innovative Rad counters, blending mill strategies with counter synergies for a fresh and unique playstyle.
Card Synergy
The deck captures the Fallout universe’s essence perfectly, with mechanics and flavor working seamlessly together.

The Magic: The Gathering Fallout Commander Deck Bundle offers four distinct 100-card decks themed around the Fallout universe, each providing a unique Commander and playstyle. These ready-to-play decks come with thematic cards and mechanics tied to their post-apocalyptic setting, which enhances card synergy and storytelling. With a solid mana base tailored for each deck's colors, players can expect smooth gameplay without frequent mana issues.

The decks include a variety of interaction and removal options, enabling players to respond to opponents' moves effectively. Specific win conditions vary across the decks and encourage diverse strategies, from aggressive to more control-oriented approaches. Card draw and ramp elements help accelerate plays and maintain hand advantage. The bundle also provides useful extras like tokens, life trackers, and strategy guides, making it beginner-friendly and convenient for multiplayer Commander battles.

As these are preconstructed decks, highly competitive players might find them less customizable or optimized compared to individually crafted decks. This bundle is well suited for fans of both Magic and Fallout who want to jump straight into thematic Commander games with ready-made, balanced decks that capture the spirit of the Fallout world.

Rating
9.8
Chosen by1,335
Commander (General)
Card Synergy

Most important from
2398 reviews

Commander (General)
The Mutant Menace deck introduces innovative Rad counters, blending mill strategies with counter synergies for a fresh and unique playstyle.
Card Synergy
The deck captures the Fallout universe’s essence perfectly, with mechanics and flavor working seamlessly together.
#2

Magic: The Gathering Bloomburrow Commander Deck - Squirreled Away (100-Card Deck, 2-Card Collector Booster Sample Pack + Accessories)

Rating
9.6
Commander (General)
Win Conditions

Most important from
987 reviews

Commander (General)
Offers a very fun and engaging gameplay experience centered on squirrel tokens.
Win Conditions
Includes alternative win conditions that add variety to the typical token swarm strategy.

The Bloomburrow Commander Deck - Squirreled Away offers a fun, thematic experience centered around squirrel tokens and creating a large army to overwhelm opponents. Its strength lies in its unique and playful theme, supported by 10 new Commander cards, including some foil versions, which adds freshness and collector value. The deck is designed for multiplayer Commander games, encouraging social and strategic play. It handles token generation well, providing solid synergy to make the most of the squirrel creatures, which feeds into its main win condition: building a wide board presence that can quickly become overwhelming.

As a ready-to-play deck, its mana base might not be optimized for competitive play compared to custom-built Commander decks, which might affect consistency in casting spells. The deck focuses heavily on token creation and offense, so interaction and removal options could be more limited, potentially making it vulnerable against decks with strong control elements. Card draw and ramp are present but not overly aggressive, which is typical for theme-focused decks aiming for fun rather than high competitiveness.

This deck suits players who enjoy a lighthearted and thematic Commander experience rather than those seeking a tier-1 competitive deck. Its components, including tokens and a deck box, make it a convenient package for newcomers or casual players looking for a ready-to-go multiplayer deck. Packing a mix of new cards and a unique theme, it provides a fresh way to explore Commander gameplay with a focus on building an army of cute but effective squirrel creatures.

Rating
9.6
Commander (General)
Win Conditions

Most important from
987 reviews

Commander (General)
Offers a very fun and engaging gameplay experience centered on squirrel tokens.
Win Conditions
Includes alternative win conditions that add variety to the typical token swarm strategy.
#3

Magic: The Gathering The Lord of The Rings: Tales of Middle-Earth Commander Deck 4 + Collector Booster Sample Pack

Rating
9.3
Commander (General)
Card Synergy

Most important from
510 reviews

Commander (General)
Seamlessly blends the rich lore of Middle-earth with Magic: The Gathering gameplay, creating an immersive and strategic experience.
Card Synergy
Features powerful blue-black-red cards and stunning foil legendary creatures that elevate the deck’s appeal.

The Lord of The Rings: Tales of Middle-Earth Commander Deck 4 offers a unique blend of Magic: The Gathering gameplay with the rich theme of Middle-earth, appealing to both Magic players and LOTR fans. It features a 100-card deck in Blue-Black-Red colors, providing a solid mana base for diverse spells and strategies. The deck introduces 20 new Commander cards, including 2 foil legendary creatures, creating fresh opportunities for interesting card synergy and exciting multiplayer battles. It includes tools for interaction and removal, which are key in Commander games, though the balance of these might favor thematic cards over highly competitive choices. The deck comes ready to play with tokens, a life tracker, and a deck box, making it convenient for newcomers and casual players. It also offers a Collector Booster Sample Pack with rare cards, adding value for collectors.

More experienced Commander players looking for finely tuned, competitive decks might find this more of a flavorful or casual option than a top-tier competitive build. Its mana base and card draw/ramp options are decent but not deeply optimized for high-level play. This deck is ideal for those who enjoy storytelling through their games and want a fun, immersive Commander experience with moderate competitiveness and strategic depth.

Rating
9.3
Commander (General)
Card Synergy

Most important from
510 reviews

Commander (General)
Seamlessly blends the rich lore of Middle-earth with Magic: The Gathering gameplay, creating an immersive and strategic experience.
Card Synergy
Features powerful blue-black-red cards and stunning foil legendary creatures that elevate the deck’s appeal.

Buying Guide for the Best Mtg Commander Decks

Choosing the right Magic: The Gathering (MTG) Commander deck can be a fun and rewarding experience. Commander is a unique format that allows for a lot of creativity and personalization. When selecting a deck, it's important to consider your play style, the type of games you enjoy, and the environment in which you'll be playing. Understanding the key specifications of a Commander deck will help you make an informed decision and ensure you have a deck that you enjoy playing and that fits your needs.
Commander (General)The Commander, also known as the General, is the centerpiece of your deck and dictates the colors you can use. This spec is crucial because it sets the tone for your deck's strategy and play style. Commanders come in various power levels and abilities. If you prefer aggressive play, look for a Commander with strong offensive capabilities. For a more control-oriented approach, choose one with abilities that disrupt opponents or protect your board. Your personal preference and play style should guide your choice here.
Mana BaseThe mana base consists of the lands and mana-producing cards in your deck. This spec is important because it ensures you can cast your spells reliably. A good mana base balances the colors needed for your deck. For a two-color deck, aim for an even split of lands that produce each color. For three or more colors, include multi-colored lands and mana-fixing cards. Consider your Commander's color requirements and the overall color distribution of your deck when building your mana base.
Card SynergyCard synergy refers to how well the cards in your deck work together to achieve your strategy. This spec is important because a deck with strong synergy will perform more consistently and effectively. Look for cards that complement your Commander's abilities and overall game plan. For example, if your Commander benefits from creature tokens, include cards that generate tokens. Evaluate your deck's theme and ensure the cards support and enhance each other.
Win ConditionsWin conditions are the ways your deck aims to achieve victory. This spec is crucial because it defines your path to winning the game. Common win conditions include combat damage, combo pieces, or alternate win conditions like milling opponents' decks. Choose win conditions that align with your play style and Commander's strengths. If you enjoy long, strategic games, consider control and combo win conditions. For faster games, focus on aggressive and combat-based strategies.
Interaction and RemovalInteraction and removal refer to the cards in your deck that deal with opponents' threats. This spec is important because it allows you to respond to and manage the board state. Include a mix of single-target removal, board wipes, and counterspells to handle various threats. The amount and type of interaction you need depend on your deck's strategy and the playgroup's meta. Ensure you have enough tools to deal with common threats without diluting your deck's main strategy.
Card Draw and RampCard draw and ramp are the cards that help you maintain resources and accelerate your game plan. This spec is important because it ensures you don't run out of cards and can play your spells efficiently. Include a balance of card draw spells and ramp cards, such as mana rocks and land-fetching spells. The right amount depends on your deck's curve and strategy. Generally, aim for a mix that keeps your hand full and your mana plentiful, allowing you to stay competitive throughout the game.

FAQ

Most Popular Categories Right Now