10 Best Paella Pan 2025 in the United States

The Sertodo Copper Alicante Paella Pan is a high-quality, 18-inch round pan made from 100% pure copper, which provides excellent even heat distribution—essential for cooking paella and similar dishes uniformly. Its 2mm thickness ensures sturdiness and versatility, making it suitable not only for paella but also for omelets, crepes, and other meals. The pan features a patented stainless steel handle designed to stay cooler and offer a comfortable grip, enhancing safety and ease of use. Weighing about 7.5 pounds, it strikes a balance between substantial heft and manageability given its large size and solid material.

This pan can be used on various heat sources including gas, electric, grills, and charcoal, and it is oven safe up to 400°F. It requires hand washing only, as it is not dishwasher safe, and the copper needs some care to maintain its appearance over time. Additionally, it includes a nonstick coating that helps with cooking and cleaning but may require using gentle utensils to avoid damage.

This pan is ideal for those who want a traditional, durable paella pan that also performs well with a range of recipes, especially if they appreciate the benefits of copper cookware. However, its weight and hand wash requirement might not be suitable for users looking for lightweight or dishwasher-friendly options.

The Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Paella Pan is a solid choice for anyone looking to cook traditional paella or use a versatile pan for sautéing and shallow frying. At about 16 inches wide, it offers a broad surface with sloped sides, which is ideal for even cooking and easy stirring. Made from carbon steel, this pan develops a natural nonstick surface when seasoned properly, avoiding synthetic coatings. The steel handle is welded without rivets, which means fewer spots for food to get stuck and easier cleaning by hand. It’s oven safe up to 800°F and works well even on induction cooktops, adding to its versatility.

The pan is not dishwasher safe and requires hand washing and seasoning to maintain the nonstick quality, which means a bit more care compared to coated pans. Weighing only 1 pound, it’s quite lightweight, which can be good for handling but may feel less sturdy for some users. This pan is ideal for those willing to invest some time in maintenance to enjoy a durable, multi-use cooking tool with authentic paella pan features.

The Mauviel M'Elite 15.7-inch Paella Pan is a high-quality option for both professional and home chefs who are serious about their cooking. Made in France and constructed with a 5-ply design, this pan offers excellent heat conductivity and even distribution, thanks to its combination of stainless steel and aluminum layers. This ensures your paella cooks evenly, which is crucial for achieving the perfect dish. Its 15.7-inch size is ample for preparing meals for multiple people, making it a great choice for gatherings. The round shape is traditional for paella pans, providing a large surface area necessary for the dish. The stay-cool handles are a thoughtful addition, offering safety and convenience when moving the pan from the stovetop to the oven.

However, note that since these handles are made of cast stainless steel, they may still get hot during extended cooking times, so using oven mitts is advisable. Maintenance could be considered a drawback for some, as this pan is not dishwasher safe and requires hand washing. Additionally, you need to be careful not to use high heat for long periods or leave the pan empty on a burner, as this can damage the pan. Metal utensils and abrasive cleaners should be avoided to keep the non-stick surface in good condition. The pan is versatile and can be used on various types of stovetops, including induction, and it is also oven safe, adding to its usability. Despite its somewhat high maintenance requirements, the superior cooking control and durable construction make it a reliable and high-performing choice for paella enthusiasts.